Thursday, June 05, 2008

In Your Mouth with Tanya Leet: Peanut Butter & Co.

I just ate a sandwich called "The Elvis" which entails peanut butter, bananas, honey and bacon, grilled like a grilled cheese. Holy shit, I was wary about the bacon but I decided to go all the way. When the lady asked me whole wheat or white bread, I was like, fuck this, I'm all in, give me some white bread. If I'm going to give myself a heart attack, I ain't gonna pussy out with some wheat bread. I had to make Elvis proud.

Apparently this was the sandwich that he ate every day, but I think he dipped his in lard. It was amazing. Warm and gooey and then a little salty crunch. Hmmm...bacon is the new black. I want to put that shit on everything. But I only allow myself bacon once a month, or I'd have it every day.

And it came with a little bag of chips and three carrot sticks. I thought the carrots were funny until I read the back of the chips the anomaly was explained thusly: the guy who opened the store did it in honor of his childhood and according to him, his mom would make him a sandwich and give him chips and carrots. The deal was, he could only eat the chips if he at the carrots too. Aren't moms so smart?

The place is adorable: like a 50s soda counter. They had fresh milk, coca-cola in a glass bottle and Stewarts (and upstate thang) brand flavored soda, along with their specialty canned peanut butter and the old staple, fluffernutter, for sale. We didn't even make it to dessert, but the milkshakes and pie sound amazing.

Check out the menu:

http://www.ilovepeanutbutter.com/sandwichshopmenu.html

ah! I just saw this: And yes, we'll cut the crusts off for you.
ah! and they have recipes!!!

Rating: If you live in NYC and love PB you must check this place out at least once.

No comments: