According to various organizations such as Zagat's, Grimaldi's brick-oven pizza is supposed to be the best in NYC.
It is not.
Julie, Gabe and I ventured to the legendary establishment on the Monday after Thanksgiving. This is probably the best day of the year to go because it was easy to get a seat and not as busy as it usually is. The inside is what you expect from an old school Italian place—small, cheesy, with framed signed photos of various Italians and famous people complete with Frank Sinatra music and checkered plastic tablecloths.
Since Julie doesn't eat pork nor red meat and Gabe doesn't eat mushrooms or olives, we were left with few toppings the three of use could agree on. Thankfully, the birthday girl made it easy by suggesting we don't corrupt our pie with accoutrements. We all agreed that plain was the way to go. We also got some house red which Julie swears comes from a box. Our headaches the next day confirm this.
The pizza arrives. I like the fresh mozarella with whole bay leaves baked in but the sauce left a lot to be desired. My grandmother's is better!
And what is the attraction to brick-oven, coal-fired pizza? Seriously? The dough/crust is always floppy and half the time you have to eat it with a knife and fork. I like the bottom of my pizza firm and crunchy. So I can pick it up and put the apex of the slice in my mouth without having to fold it or hold it up with my other had because it's fucking flaccid. Fuck.
We befriended the older couple next to us and they agreed.
"Best pizza in new york?" I asked.
"God, I hope not," said the gentleman from North Carolina.
"Fuck no," said my boyfriend, who later had to stop at McDonald's for a late night snack on account of the pizza not being satisfying enough. (Disclaimer: I ate some fries)
In conclusion, this place is more of a tourist destination and DUMBO icon than it is a culinary marvel. While I don't know what the best pizza in New York is, it sure isn't under the Brooklyn Bridge.
New Godflesh & Jesu with Phoebe too
1 month ago