Through the grapevine (re: my friend Kahlil) I heard about this place in Brooklyn that's supposed to have the best pizza in NYC. This is also according to the blog of The Yeah Yeah Yeahs drummer.
I know, it's been said about Patsy's and Grimaldi's, etc. but this is supposed to be the real deal. Since we were heading out to Coney Island for Siren Festival, we made a pit stop in Midwood to check it out for ourselves.
It's right off the Q and a small little place with an open kitchen, so you can watch the 80-year-old master at work. There was a line and I was warned in advance that there would be a wait. Everyone in line confirmed tha it was worth the wait.
I still wasn't expecting to wait an hour. Especially on a blistering hot day. I suspect that my order was skipped by a regular (who claimed he was bringing the pies to Bill Cosby), a dude who spoke Italian and the need to offer slices. I was surprised they even offered slices; I know John's Pizza on Bleecker doesn't. That's another place in the BEST PIZZA running.
During this time, I got to witness how it's done. Domenico rolls out the dough, spreads his handmade sauce, then lays down huge chunks of mozzarella and drizzles some oiive oil on top. When it's done, he cuts some fresh basil to put on top, adds some more cheese (can't tell if it was different or the same) then drizzles even MORE E.V.O.O. on it.
So it's cheesy, oily and delicious. My only complaint is that the dough is too thin...creating that flaccid pizza that I'm not a fan of. You may have read my diatribe against this when I was reviewing Grimaldi's a while back.
Gabe hated it; I think it was mainly because we had to wait so long so he was all fired up and annoyed. The one problem solid complaint he had was that there wasn't enough sauce.
A lot of the reviews and write ups mention the beauty in the imperfection of the pie. Like more cheese over here, thicker dough at one point, etc. I would agree with this description: Too much uniformity seems mass produced and manufactured, so I like that fact that some guy spends time crafting each one uniquely.
So go during the day, or during the week to beat the crowds. At one point, the 2nd in command stopped taking orders because they had to make more dough—many people left disappointed. Maybe even call ahead with your order if they take them over the phone.
Rating: Maybe the BEST PIZZA, maybe not, but it sure is close